| |
Shame: The Power Behind Secrecy in Non-Traditional Family Building
Secrecy has been the 'buzz' word for the infertile as
they struggle to have the family they so desperately
want. Keeping the secret has done more to impede awareness
and public understanding of the plight of the infertile.
Individuals were counseled, convinced, advised, and
even coerced into keeping their reproductive activities
quiet. The guise of privacy served as the political
tactic to supposedly aid and abet the infertile.
From the archives of adoption practices, through the
establishment of sperm banking, to the more recent development
of egg donation programs, secrecy disguised as privacy
has been the touted conventional wisdom.
Reproductive practitioners counsel and advise their
patients to keep their reproductive choices quiet so
no one will know that their child is not biologically
related to one or both parents. The purported purpose
allows parents to live their lives without the fear
of being ostracized. This makes perfect sense on one
level, but makes little sense when you examine the bigger
picture.
Whenever one questions the motivations for maintaining
the secret you only have to dig a little deeper to uncover
the "shame" that is associated with not being able to
have children in the traditional way. Shame about failing
at traditional procreation, shame about not having a
genetically conceived baby, shame about being prodded,
poked, examined, and intruded upon, and shame about
not being man enough, woman enough, or whole enough.
It is the shame that wrecks havoc on the infertile's
life, and fuels the discomfort of the family building
process. Infertility is a difficult enough experience
without the explosive component of shame. It is the
shame that builds walls between people whether it be
between family members or friends. It forces one to
isolate oneself and withdraw from life's happenings.
Shame sets up barriers between people
and inhibits the development of relationships and unimpeded
communication. It contributes to an individualÕs feeling
self consciousness and discomfort as they work hard
to protect the secret. Secrets can have a corrupting
influence on family life. If we are to legitimize and
respect alternative ways of building families, we must
question what it is we are needing to protect.
Are nontraditional family building options shameful?
If they are not, then we are obligated to rethink our
position on secrecy. And this perhaps could be the greatest
legacy the infertile can offer to their children - the
children that are here and the children that will be
here soon.
|